Peter McMurtrie

Peter brings over three decades of experience guiding organizations through complex transformations that optimize performance and drive tangible results. Recently, he helped a national commercial lines carrier implement process and data initiatives that reduced expenses by $200 million over three years. Peter’s expertise spans sales, marketing, claims, and customer interactions, with extensive experience working with C-suites and boards of directors.

Before joining West Monroe, Peter was president of Property & Casualty Commercial Insurance at Nationwide, where he oversaw key national broker relationships. He holds a bachelor’s degree from the University of South Florida and has completed executive education programs at Wharton.

Peter’s All-In Mindset

An avid cyclist, Peter enjoys road and mountain biking on the trails near his home. He also dedicates his time to supporting Central Ohio organizations that serve children with behavioral and developmental challenges.